Guidance You Can Understand. Counsel You Can Trust.
Guidance You Can Understand. Counsel You Can Trust.
Whitney’s Career Highlights
- Nominated and Accepted into the Lawyers of Distinction for 2025 with a focus on excellence in family law.
- Voted Best Law Firm in Abingdon Virginia 2025.
- Board of Trustee Member for the Morrison School in Bristol, Virginia since 2024.
- Served as Assistant Attorney General who litigated over 3,000 child support cases including enforcement and establishment actions.
- Served as magistrate to aid community members who were seeking criminal charges, protective orders and mental health custody orders.
- Represented clients and litigated against attorneys from Northern Virginia to Southwest Virginia.
- A decade of focused practice solely on all family law matters including custody, child support, spousal support, and both contested and uncontested divorces.
- A decade of experience in drafting wills, powers of attorney, and advanced medical directives.
- Extensive understanding of enforceability and modification of out of state orders.
Purpose
The Pennington Law Firm helps clients navigate difficult life events like divorce and secure their family’s future through estate planning. The firm aims to provide quality legal representation at a reasonable price, helping clients get their lives back on track quickly.
Approach
Values
The firm provides compassionate support, effective problem-solving, and personalized attention to every situation. Our team is focused on providing professional, straightforward advice to every client.
Our Team
Emily Fleenor
Attorney
Emily focuses her practice on family law and estate planning, serving clients throughout…
Emily Fleenor
Attorney
Emily focuses her practice on family law and estate planning, serving clients throughout Southwest Virginia with compassion, diligence, and clear communication. Since joining Pennington Law Firm two years ago, Emily has guided individuals and families through a wide range of legal matters, from highly contested disputes to proactive planning.
In the area of family law, Emily handles both contested and uncontested divorces, custody and visitation matters, premarital and postnuptial agreements, and post-divorce enforcement issues. She is especially drawn to family law because of the opportunity it offers to help clients navigate some of the most personal and emotionally challenging moments of their lives. Whether a matter requires strategic negotiation or litigation, Emily is committed to protecting her clients’ interests while providing grounded, empathetic support throughout the process.
Emily also maintains a robust estate planning practice. She assists clients in developing comprehensive plans that reflect their wishes and protect their families. Her estate work includes drafting wills, powers of attorney, and advance medical directives, as well as designing trusts-including special needs trusts-for families with complex planning needs. Emily also regularly works with families navigating adult guardianship and conservatorship proceedings, helping them find practical, compassionate solutions for protecting loved ones.
A native of Abingdon, Emily earned her undergraduate degree from James Madison University in 2019, majoring in Political Science and minoring in History. During college, she returned home each summer to intern with Arrington Schelin in Bristol, Virginia, gaining early exposure to legal practice in her community.
She went on to earn her law degree from New England Law | Boston, where she was immersed in the city’s fast-paced and diverse legal environment. Before returning to Southwest Virginia, Emily worked at a high-volume personal injury firm in Boston for two years. There, she focused on evaluating the trial viability of claims and learned the importance of keeping clients informed throughout the litigation process.
Emily was admitted to the Virginia State Bar in 2023. She is proud to be back in her hometown and honored to serve the people of the region she calls home. In her spare time, Emily enjoys traveling, reading, playing with her three dogs, and spending time with her family and friends.
Renee Davenport
Paralegal
Renee serves as a dedicated paralegal at the firm, where she brings warmth, efficiency…
Renee Davenport
Paralegal
Renee serves as a dedicated paralegal at the firm, where she brings warmth, efficiency, and over two years of hands-on experience supporting clients and attorneys alike. Renee ensures that communications are timely, clients feel heard, and matters move forward with care and precision.
Originally from Abingdon, Virginia, Renee spent over 25 years living and working across the United States with her husband, a career military servicemember who also hails from Abingdon. They recently returned to the area to reconnect with their roots and be closer to family and friends.
Outside the office, Renee enjoys doting on her dogs, expanding her impressive shoe collection, experimenting in the kitchen with new recipes, and watching British crime dramas.
Josie Sturgill
Josie was born in Key West, Florida, and grew up as part of a military family, living in…
Josie Sturgill
Josie was born in Key West, Florida, and grew up as part of a military family, living in several states before making Southwest Virginia home more than 16 years ago.
She is a graduate of Liberty University and holds two master’s degrees, one in Human Services with a focus on Marriage and Family, and an MBA with a focus in Human Resources. With over a decade of clerical and administrative experience across a variety of fields, Josie enjoys bringing strong organizational and people-focused skills to her role at the firm each day.
At home in Chilhowie, Josie and her husband, Daniel, stay busy with their young daughter and two Yorkies. In her free time, she enjoys quality with family and friends, reading a good book, and traveling-especially when it means relaxing by the ocean or discovering somewhere new.
Whitney Pennington
Founder and Principal Attorney, Pennington Law Firm, PLLC
Being a lawyer was not where I thought my career path would lead. My original ambition was to be an English teacher. However, as I pursued my degree at my hometown college, Virginia Intermont, I found that I wanted to not only teach others but advocate for others as well. I graduated with highest honors from Virginia Intermont and pursued my law degree from Campbell University’s Norman Adrian Wiggins School of Law. In 2012 I graduated from Campbell with high honors and passed the North Carolina Bar. I returned home to Southwest Virginia and became licensed in Virginia in early 2013. As of late 2025, I have been provisionally accepted into the Tennessee Bar to further expand my practice and those I serve.
For over 12 years I have served my community in many capacities. For the first year of my practice, I served as a magistrate who aided both the public and law enforcement with criminal charges, search warrants and mental health emergency custody orders. In my second year of practice, I served as a Title IX Coordinator at Shenandoah University in Winchester, Virginia where I was responsible for hearing and adjudicating claims involving student’s academic and sexual misconduct claims.
But what has always had my heart, soul, and passion is advocating for families. For a decade now I have dedicated my practice to serving my community as a divorce and estate planning attorney. I must be a glutton for punishment because I picked two of the most emotionally challenging phases of a person’s life to be my primary focuses of advocacy. Life, death, marriage, and divorce, affect everyone regardless of status, wealth, education or ethnicity and I meet them head on every single day.
Contested divorces are gut wrenching, financially draining, and mentally tiresome. Most attorneys refuse to handle any contested divorce because of the emotional toil, time and energy clients require throughout their separation and ultimate divorce. Likewise, estate planning requires deep thought and precise use of language.
In my decade of practice, I have litigated and negotiated more divorces and custody disputes than I can count. I have also prepared more wills, powers of attorney, advanced medical directives and trusts then I could possibly number.
I have represented individuals with large wealth portfolios and those who were living paycheck to paycheck. Regardless of financial status, all clients deserve someone who will genuinely listen and then offer honest but practical advice. There are times clients need a pit bull to fight and there are times clients need someone who can tactfully negotiate an agreement with discernment and grace. While I am not afraid of any fight in a courtroom, I can also negotiate agreements with a firm hand and strategic approach.
With almost every consult or client I encounter, I often wear many hats- lawyer, advisor, therapist, scape goat, pit bull, and most often the shoulder to lean and cry on. I see people on their worst days. I often bear the brunt of their anger, hurt and fear. I watch people fall apart. But…. I also get to see people find happiness, freedom, stability and emotional well-being. And for me there is no greater purpose or higher calling. I am blessed beyond all measure and called to this higher purpose. I end with this verse “Let us not grow weary in well doing- for in due season we will reap a harvest if we do not give up.”
Whether you need a pit bull or a negotiator I hope you give us a call.
As always, I hope to see you soon.
Suggested Action Points:
- Nominated and Accepted into the Lawyers of Distinction for 2025 with a focus on excellence in family law.
- Voted Best Law Firm in Abingdon Virginia 2025
- Board of Trustee Member for the Morrison School in Bristol, Virginia since 2024.
- Served as Assistant Attorney General who litigated over 3,000 child support cases including enforcement and establishment actions.
- Served as magistrate to aid community members who were seeking criminal charges, protective orders and mental health custody orders.
- Represented clients and litigated against attorneys from Northern Virginia to Southwest Virginia.
- A decade of focused practice solely on all family law matters including custody, child support, spousal support, and both contested and uncontested divorces.
- A decade of experience in drafting wills, powers of attorney, and advanced medical directives.
- Extensive understanding of enforceability and modification of out of state orders.